Mark A. Carter


World famous Canadian Science Fiction writer Mark A. Carter reprints an article from written by Natalie Wolchover from April 13, 2012 to refute the premise in Christopher Nolan's film Interstellar that a human being can pass through a Black Hole intact. According to British Astrophysicist Sir Martin Rees, if you fell into a Black Hole, your brain and body would dissociate instantly into subatomic particles, and stetch in a process he calls spaghettification.

Simulated view of a black hole of the Large Magellanic Cloud

Credit: Alain R | Wikipedia Commons

Note: the original title of this article was "What Would Happen If You Fell into a Black Hole?"

Black holes are without question some of the strangest places in the universe. They are so massive that they hideously deform space and time. They are so dense that their centers are called points at infinity. And they are pitch-black because not even light can escape them. It isn't surprising that so many people wonder what it would be like to visit one?

It's not exactly a restive vacation spot, as it turns out.

"If you were to take a step into a black hole, your body would most closely resemble toothpaste being extruded out of the tube," said Charles Liu, an Astrophysicist who works at the American Museum of Natural History's Hayden Planetarium.

Liu said that when an object crosses a black hole's event horizon or its outer boundary, or point of no return, the same physics that causes Earth's ocean tides begins to take effect. Gravity's strength decreases with distance, so the moon pulls on the side of the Earth closer to it a bit more vigorously than the side farther from it, and as a result, Earth elongates ever so slightly in the direction of the moon. The land is sturdy, so it doesn't move much, but the water on Earth's surface is fluid, so it flows along the elongated axis. "That's the tidal interaction," he said.

Rising tides are about as calming a scene as there is. But if a human being was to stick his big toe over the event horizon of a black hole not so much.

Near a black hole roughly the size of Earth, tidal forces are magnified off the scale. Swan-diving into one, the top of your head would feel so much more gravitational pull than the tips of your toes that you would be stretched, longer and longer. The British Astrophysicist Sir Martin Rees coined the term spaghettification, which is a perfectly good way to put it. You eventually become a stream of subatomic particles that swirl into the black hole.

Because your brain would dissociate into its constituent atoms almost instantly, you'd have little opportunity to soak in the scenery at the threshold of an Earth-size black hole.

However, if you're dead set on visiting a space-time singularity, we recommend going big. Bigger black holes have less extreme surfaces. "If you had a black hole the size of our solar system, then the tidal forces at the event horizon would not be that strong. So you could actually maintain your structural integrity," Liu said.

In that case, you would get to experience the effects of the curvature of space-time, predicted by Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, first hand.

"First of all, you approach the speed of light as you fall into the black hole. So the faster you move through space, the slower you move through time," he said. "Furthermore, as you fall, there are things that have been falling in front of you that have experienced an even greater time dilation than you have. So if you're able to look forward toward the black hole, you see every object that has fallen into it in the past. And then if you look backwards, you'll be able to see everything that will ever fall into the black hole behind you."

"So the upshot is you'll get to see the entire history of that spot in the universe simultaneously," he said, "from the Big Bang all the way into the distant future."

Not such a bad way to go, in the grand scheme of things.

So, the way I understand this, Joe Cooper's chance of surviving the journey through the Black Hole named Gargantua, in Christopher Nolan's film Interstellar is non-existent. At best it is highly improbable, most likely impossible, but nevertheless utterly unbelieveable. Most predictably, Cooper would be crushed and stretched into non-existence. For human beings, travelling through a Black Hole is the equivalent of being disintegrated. And much like Humpty Dumpty, once you fall off the wall, you cannot be put back together again.


Read: Black Hole birth of the universe
Center of a Black Hole
Magnetars should freak you out
Tachyons and Big Bangs

Now you know.

from the imagination of Mark A. Carter - writer

Book Store | HOME | Use the Site Map  to navigate.

Bluebird Hosting provides simplified hosting in Canada.

You get Powerful, Reliable and Secure Hosting with

unlimited features for as low as $3.99/month.